PopCreate vs ThumbnailTest
Both offer A/B testing. But where do you create the thumbnails you're testing? PopCreate includes a full editor. ThumbnailTest doesn't.
Choose ThumbnailTest if you...
- Already have a design workflow you love
- Only need testing, nothing else
- Want the most mature testing platform
- Need hourly rotation specifically
Choose PopCreate if you...
- Want to create AND test in one place
- Need AI generation + manual editing
- Want deeper analytics with AI insights
- Prefer one subscription for everything
Feature by Feature
| Feature | PopCreate | ThumbnailTest |
|---|---|---|
| A/B Testing | ✓ Unlimited on Pro | ✓ Unlimited |
| Title Testing | ✓ Available | ✓ Available |
| Rotation Options | ✓ Hourly + Daily | ✓ Hourly + Daily |
| Statistical Analysis | ✓ Z-test with CI | ✓ Available |
| Thumbnail Editor | ✓ Full AI editor | ✗ Not included |
| AI Thumbnail Generation | ✓ Gemini + Flux | ✗ Not available |
| Smart Selection | ✓ SAM-powered | ✗ Not available |
| YouTube Analytics | ✓ Full dashboard | ⚠️ Test metrics only |
| AI Recommendations | ✓ Available | ✗ Not available |
| Free Plan | ✓ 2 tests/month | ✗ No free plan |
Pricing Comparison
ThumbnailTest
Basic: ~$15/mo (1 channel)
Pro: ~$29/mo (3 channels)
Business: ~$79/mo (10 channels)
A/B testing only—you need Canva, Photoshop, or another tool to create thumbnails.
PopCreate
Free: $0 (2 tests, 5 AI gens)
Pro: $19/mo (unlimited tests)
Agency: $79/mo (team features)
Testing + Creation + Analytics—everything you need in one subscription.
With ThumbnailTest + Canva Pro, you're paying $15 + $13 = $28/mo minimum. PopCreate Pro is $19/mo for everything.
The Key Difference
ThumbnailTest is testing-only. You create thumbnails somewhere else, upload them, and test. Great if you already have a design workflow.
PopCreate is end-to-end. Create thumbnails with AI assistance, test them automatically, and get insights on why they performed. All in one place.
The workflow matters: Integrated tools mean faster iteration. See test results, make changes, and test again without switching apps.
ThumbnailTest: Canva → Export → Upload → Test → Canva → Repeat
PopCreate: Create → Test → Analyze → Edit → Test → Done
What ThumbnailTest Does Well
We believe in fair comparisons. Here's where ThumbnailTest shines:
🏆 Battle-Tested
They've been doing A/B testing longer. Their system is mature and reliable.
📊 Detailed Metrics
20+ metrics for analyzing test results. Very granular data.
🔌 Zapier Integration
Automation capabilities for advanced workflows.
Want More Than Just Testing?
Try PopCreate free and experience the all-in-one difference.